Become a member and get exclusive access to articles, contests and more!
Start Your Free Trial

Helping ‘Tipping Point’ species: Collaborating on a landscape scale

Tipping Point species
Cerulean Warbler. Photo by Andrew Spencer, Cornell Lab/Macaulay Library

This year’s State of the Birds report represents a dire warning about the future of many U.S. avian species if current trends continue. While waterfowl are on the rise thanks to wetlands-focused conservation efforts, nearly every other group of birds is declining. The report identifies 90 species that have lost at least half of their breeding population in the last 50 years but are not protected as Threatened or Endangered under the Endangered Species Act. Of these species, 70 are considered “Tipping Point” species because they are on track to lose half their population again in the next 50 years.

But hope is not lost. Collaborative conservation efforts have recently slowed and even halted population declines in the other 20 species. Two of these, the Cerulean Warbler and the Wood Thrush, are even increasing in population in some parts of their range. This is thanks, in large part, to the Appalachian Mountains Joint Venture (AMJV), a regional partnership headed by American Bird Conservancy (ABC) and made up of more than 55 government agencies, nonprofits, and universities.

ABC sat down with AMJV Coordinator Todd Fearer, a scientific advisor on the report, to talk about what it has taken to set these species on a path toward recovery, plans to build on success so far, and how the model can be replicated for species across the United States.

Todd Fearer, coordinator of the Appalachian Mountain Joint Venture.

You are the director of the AMJV — can you explain what that is and how it operates?

Advertisement
Advertisement

The AMJV was established in 2008 as one of 21 U.S. Migratory Bird Joint Ventures (MBJVs). We are administered by ABC through a cooperative agreement with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

The essence of the AMJV is its partnerships, with the JV providing a nexus that enables collaborative conservation across the landscape. Our success really comes from what AMJV core staff help partner organizations and agencies achieve on the ground. A lot of the JV’s bird conservation work involves collaborating to enhance and protect forest habitat for birds in line with established national bird conservation plans.

AMJV staff provide regional planning, project coordination and development, and networking resources to connect the conservation community. AMJV partners — including our management board, technical committee, and regional partnerships — provide financial, technical, and local expertise to deliver conservation projects on the ground.

You also represent the MBVJs on the U.S. NABCI Committee and are on the Road to Recovery (R2R) team that contributed to the State of the Birds 2022 report. Can you explain your role in crafting the report and how the AMJV/ABC fits into that group?

Advertisement
Advertisement

The U.S. NABCI Committee is responsible for producing the State of the Birds (SOTB) reports, and I’ve served on the SOTB Subcommittee for the last three reports. I’m also on the R2R Organizing Committee, serving as a liaison with the MBJVs and providing guidance on how R2R can best augment our work and vice versa. The premise of R2R is to develop a process for reversing bird declines, especially declines in “Tipping Point” species — birds that are high priorities for science and conservation because of their high vulnerability to extinction.

There are several linkages between NABCI, R2R, and the AMJV/ABC. For instance, the AMJV is adopting the R2R framework in our efforts to address Cerulean Warbler declines. While we generally know what’s causing their decline, there are specifics we still don’t understand. Given the scope not only of our Cerulean work, but the broader R2R effort, NABCI serves as a central nexus around which to move forward as a unified strategic effort, reducing the risk of duplicating effort or competing for resources.

The AMJV has put a lot of effort into the conservation of two bird species in particular — the Cerulean Warbler and the Wood Thrush. Why focus on these two species?

Advertisement
Advertisement

We have over one-third of the global Wood Thrush population within the AMJV, and almost 75 percent of the Cerulean Warbler population, so we obviously have a major conservation responsibility for them. Both of these species have declined significantly in the past several decades within the Appalachian Region. Since the mid 1960s, we’ve lost approximately 75 percent of the Cerulean population and 60 percent of Wood Thrush. The health of these two species also happens to be a good representation of forest health and resilience in general, so we know that conservation actions for these species benefit the entire system.

What has the AMJV done to address threats to these species?

Our work is informed by the best available science about the breeding habits of both species, as well as sustainable forest management guidelines. In 2020 we enhanced 8,753 acres of habitat on private lands in West Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Maryland and reforested 677 acres of legacy surface mine land in Ohio and Kentucky.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Currently, much of our work is occurring in six Focal Landscapes, equivalent to ABC’s Birdscapes, across the AMJV geography, which are featured in the SOTB report. Through these Focal Landscapes, we’re strategically targeting our capacity and resources to high-priority regions established by the AMJV partners. Amanda Duren, AMJV Director of Conservation Partnerships, leads this work.

This approach maximizes conservation impacts for our priority species. Since we launched the effort in 2017, we’ve worked with partners to receive 14 grant-funded projects, resulting in a $4 million investment in forest management, with at least one project awarded in each Focal Landscape.

Finally, we’re trying to expand our work to have a full annual life cycle-driven approach and address conservation issues across all parts of that cycle. These birds are also migratory, and conservation will only be successful if we’re working across that full migratory pathway: breeding habitat, migratory stopover habitat, and wintering habitat. Becky Keller, our AMJV Science Coordinator, leads our AMJV Full Annual Cycle Team, and I recently revived the Cerulean Warbler Technical Group to help coordinate conservation actions across the Cerulean’s range, especially their nonbreeding grounds.

Wood Thrush. Photo by Janet Heintz

Now Cerulean Warbler and Wood Thrush populations are actually increasing in some of your work areas. What contributed to your success in these places?

Advertisement
Advertisement

There are a lot of things likely contributing to these increases, and in all cases this success is really a function of the collaborative efforts of AMJV partners. The areas highlighted in the SOTB report with some of the biggest increases are areas that our partners have been working in for some time, even before they were officially deemed Focal Landscapes in 2017. In fact, many of our Focal Landscapes were established not only because they’re important areas for our priority species, but also to build on and strengthen existing partner networks and expertise so we weren’t starting from scratch. 

The AMJV treats each landscape as a holistic system, with participating partners identifying the objectives for each landscape, including priorities that are not bird-centric. We also worked very closely with the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation when they established their Central Appalachia Habitat Stewardship Program in 2017. This program covers the northern half of our JV and provides funding for forest management projects. All that said, our work is far from done. There are many factors that affect those trends, and anyone who is involved with bird conservation knows that they can change direction quickly.

What advice do you have for others hoping to replicate your success with Tipping Point species across the U.S.?

Advertisement
Advertisement

First, embrace an approach that seeks to engage all relevant partners and brings them to the table from the start. I think this has been key for our Focal Landscapes. We worked with our partners to develop an agreed-upon set of overarching criteria for establishing all of our Focal Landscapes, then allowed partners to determine their boundaries, rather than us pointing to a place on the map and saying, “Put one here.”

 Second, take a holistic approach to conservation. The SOTB report provides some great examples of how bird conservation can contribute to broader conservation priorities, from carbon sequestration to ground water recharge. Understanding and embracing those broader benefits can open the door to novel partnerships as well as get more buy-in from established partners, such as state agencies, because the work is addressing many of their priorities in addition to birds.

Finally, what are you hoping that people take away from the 2022 State of the Birds report?

Advertisement
Advertisement

We can do this! It’s easy to look at the trends of some of the species, especially the Tipping Point species, and become disheartened.  But the point of this SOTB report is to highlight the successes that show we can turn things around and the opportunities we have now to make it happen, and I think that’s the key point. Many in the bird conservation community talk about the uniqueness of this moment in time — about how we’re at a threshold of some really big opportunities and changes. At no other point in recent history has conservation received so much attention with so many resources made available for action on the ground, with even more, hopefully, on the horizon. And if there was ever a time we needed to make this a reality, it’s now. The essay in the report by Dr. Drew Lanham really brings this home — our work isn’t just about bird conservation, it’s for all of us.

Read more about the 2022 State of the Birds report

Read our newsletter!

Sign up for our free e-newsletter to receive news, photos of birds, attracting and ID tips, and more delivered to your inbox.

Sign Up for Free
American Bird Conservancy

American Bird Conservancy

American Bird Conservancy is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization whose mission is to conserve native birds and their habitats throughout the Americas. It contributes the “Eye on Conservation” column in each issue of BirdWatching.

American Bird Conservancy on social media